Artificial Intelligence in Business: How to Turn Technology into Business Results
Zallpy
Verified Author
6 November
LLM as a Judge and Human in the Loop are two approaches used to evaluate the quality of artificial intelligence applications. In the first, a language model analyzes another model’s responses and assigns scores to them. In the second, people participate in different stages of the evaluation process. The question in the title is often framed as if you had to choose one or the other. But, in my view, that is a false choice. One approach depends on the other, as I will explain throughout this article.
Anyone working in Quality Assurance, software testing, or development has probably noticed that AI is now being used in increasingly complex processes. As a result, some fundamental questions about testing strategies have returned in a different form: How do you find errors in a system whose responses change with every execution? How can you determine whether an AI-generated response is reliable enough to reach the end user?
Answering these questions requires understanding how each evaluation strategy works, where each one falls short, and when the cost of implementing it makes sense.
In traditional software, testing verifies whether the actual result matches the expected one. A feature receives an input, performs an operation, and returns an output that can be compared against a predefined result. This is what ISTQB standards call a test oracle, the source that tells us what the correct behavior should be.
With Large Language Models (LLMs), building this oracle becomes much more difficult. Models are non-deterministic, meaning the same input can generate different responses across separate executions. There is also not always a single correct answer that can serve as a reference.
Defining what constitutes an error is equally challenging. A response may be grammatically flawless but contain false information. It may address only part of the request or overlook context that is actually the most important element from a business perspective.
Evaluation, therefore, depends on specific criteria (accuracy, relevance, coherence, context, and adherence to instructions) and on a method capable of applying those criteria consistently. This goes far beyond simply comparing inputs and outputs.
I see LLM as a Judge as an important part of meta-quality: the process of verifying the quality of QA artifacts and processes themselves. When the application being evaluated is also an AI system, the same logic applies. Before trusting the evaluation, we need to ensure that the evaluation process itself is reliable.
This is where the two approaches come in. I prefer to start with the human side because it provides the reference point for everything else.
Human in the Loop (HITL) is an approach that incorporates human participation into the development, evaluation, or operation lifecycle of an artificial intelligence system.
In practice, professionals review responses, correct results, classify information, or approve actions suggested by AI. By doing so, they bring something into the evaluation process that models rarely interpret well on their own: business context, language nuances, and the consequences of a decision.
This participation can happen at four different points in an application’s lifecycle.
At the input stage, people curate data, define prompts, and select test cases.
During evaluation, specialists build reference datasets (known as golden sets) and establish the criteria against which responses will be judged.
At the output stage, someone reviews or approves the result before it produces practical consequences, such as sending a communication, changing a record, or executing an operation.
Finally, in production, samples of responses and user feedback are analyzed to identify failures that earlier tests did not anticipate.
The most valuable contribution of Human in the Loop is contextual judgment, which is essentially domain knowledge applied to evaluation.
A specialist can recognize when a response is inappropriate even if it appears correct, interpret situations that require specific expertise, and account for details that were not covered by the model’s instructions.
Those who follow my work know how much importance I place on domain knowledge. Here, it comes back as a criterion for AI evaluation.
This becomes even more important in higher-risk applications, where an incorrect response can have financial, operational, or direct consequences for users.
There is also a second role that is often overlooked: human evaluation provides the reference against which automated evaluators are validated. Specialists’ assessments reveal failures, refine quality criteria, and help calibrate the models used as judges.
The limitations of an exclusively human evaluation process are familiar to anyone who has had to size a testing team: scale, time, and cost.
Manually reviewing a large volume of responses requires dedicated people and makes the process slower, especially in applications that generate thousands of results every day.
Consistency is another concern. Two evaluators may interpret the same response differently. Fatigue and subjectivity can influence even the assessments of experienced professionals.
What helps reduce this variation is process discipline: documented criteria, multiple evaluators for relevant samples, and ongoing measurement of agreement levels between them.
With this structure in place, human evaluation can serve as a reliable reference and feed improvements back into the process at every cycle.
LLM as a Judge is an evaluation technique in which a language model acts as an evaluator of responses generated by another model.
Instead of relying on a person to check every result, a second model analyzes the output based on predefined criteria.
The judge model receives the original question, the generated response, and instructions explaining what it should consider. From there, it can assign a score, determine whether the response meets the criteria, or explain the reasoning behind its assessment.
There are three main ways to apply this technique:
Direct scoring: The judge assigns a score (from 1 to 5, for example) based on criteria such as accuracy, relevance, clarity, and adherence to instructions.
Response comparison: The judge receives two responses and determines which one better meets the criteria. This is useful for comparing models, prompts, or different versions of an application.
Reference-based evaluation: The response is compared against reference information or the context provided. This helps identify inconsistencies and hallucinations, particularly in applications using Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG).
The most obvious advantage is scalability. While manual review depends on professionals’ time and availability, a judge model can analyze thousands of responses in a short period.
This makes it possible to incorporate evaluation into development and Continuous Integration (CI) pipelines. Every change to prompts, models, or datasets can be accompanied by regression tests, allowing potential quality degradation to be identified before it reaches production.
Another benefit is standardization. With well-defined evaluation instructions, the judge applies the same rubric to every response, making it easier to track quality throughout development.
The same rubric also allows teams to establish minimum thresholds. A response that fails to achieve the expected score for a particular criterion is treated as a failure and sent for further analysis, just as we would handle a defect in any other software project.
Using one AI model to evaluate another does not eliminate the risk of inconsistency. The judge is also a model. It is also non-deterministic and subject to biases.
Some common examples include a preference for longer responses, a tendency to favor the first option presented in a comparison, and a bias toward responses generated by models similar to itself.
If these behaviors are not considered during implementation, the reliability of the results is compromised. The team may end up making decisions based on a number that looks objective but actually isn’t.
Automation is software and, as such, must be tested like any other software. The judge model is a Quality artifact and deserves the same treatment.
A few practices can help:
Choosing a judge model is also a Quality cost decision.
Not every task requires a high-capability model, and using the most sophisticated option at every stage increases processing costs without necessarily delivering proportional benefits.
A more sensible approach is to distribute the workload according to complexity. More economical models can handle repetitive, standardized evaluations, while more advanced models can be reserved for analyses that require stronger interpretation capabilities or for orchestrating the evaluation process itself.
The question is the same one we should ask about any QA tool: How much does the evaluation cost compared with the value it provides?
The right balance between cost, performance, and quality should be determined on a task-by-task basis.
Both.
Let me return to what I said at the beginning: treating LLM as a Judge and Human in the Loop as mutually exclusive alternatives means looking for a silver bullet that, as Fred Brooks warned back in 1986, does not exist.
The approaches address different needs and complement each other depending on the application’s objectives, complexity, and risks.
The main distinction lies in how they evaluate results: automated judges provide speed and processing capacity at scale, while people contribute contextual interpretation and specialized judgment.
| Criteria | LLM as a Judge | Human in the Loop |
|---|---|---|
| Scalability | Evaluates large volumes of responses quickly. | Limited by evaluators’ time and availability. |
| Cost per evaluation | Generally lower for recurring, automated evaluations. | Higher due to the need for professional involvement. |
| Consistency | Maintains standards when the rubric is well-defined, but remains subject to biases. | Varies according to each evaluator’s interpretation. |
| Context and interpretation | Limited to the information and criteria provided to the model. | Incorporates specialized knowledge and business context. |
| Main limitations | Model biases and potential inconsistencies in evaluations. | Subjectivity, execution time, and scalability challenges. |
| Recommended applications | Regression testing, triage, and continuous monitoring. | Calibration, result validation, and higher-risk decisions. |
The approach I consider most effective uses human evaluation as the reference for structuring and calibrating automated evaluation.
From that foundation, the judge takes over the work that can be performed at scale, while people focus their efforts on cases that require closer attention.
The process can be organized into five steps:
1. Define the criteria
Professionals establish what constitutes a high-quality response and manually evaluate an initial set of examples. This becomes the reference dataset for the process.
2. Calibrate the judge model
The judge is configured and tested against those examples, making it possible to measure agreement between automated and human evaluations.
3. Automate evaluations
Once calibrated, the judge analyzes responses at scale, integrated into development pipelines and production monitoring.
4. Review critical cases
Responses with low scores, inconsistent results, or low confidence levels are flagged for human review.
5. Continuously improve
Insights from human reviews are used to update criteria, refine rubrics, and expand the reference dataset.
With this arrangement, human participation is no longer spread thin across the review of every response. Instead, it is directed toward the situations where it makes the greatest difference.
At the same time, automated evaluation gains a more reliable reference, reducing the risk of decisions based exclusively on another model’s judgment.
You don’t need to start with a complex structure. Maturity is a progression, and the first step is establishing clear criteria and a process that can evolve alongside the application.
For QAs, testers, and developers, I would suggest the following sequence:
Evaluation does not end when an application reaches production.
Continuous monitoring is what reveals changes in model behavior, previously unanticipated failure scenarios, and opportunities for improvement.
AI quality, like any other aspect of Quality, is a process that spans development, testing, monitoring, and review.
It is a technique in which one language model evaluates responses generated by another model based on predefined criteria. The result can be a score, a verdict, or an explanation of the response’s quality.
It is an approach that incorporates people into the lifecycle of an AI application, whether during data preparation, response evaluation, result correction, or approval of actions before they are executed.
No. Automated evaluation can analyze large volumes of responses much faster, but it remains subject to biases and inconsistencies.
People are still necessary to establish criteria, calibrate models, and review situations that require specialized knowledge or involve higher levels of risk.
In non-deterministic applications, evaluation cannot rely exclusively on comparing results against an exact expected response.
The solution is to establish quality criteria and minimum thresholds, test different inputs, and analyze response samples.
A failure is then defined as a result that does not meet the requirements established for that particular use case.
Evaluating artificial intelligence applications requires adapting traditional testing practices to the characteristics of language models.
Since responses vary from one execution to another, validation must rely on quality criteria, context, and acceptable performance levels. Simply comparing outputs is no longer enough.
LLM as a Judge provides the scale and speed needed to automate evaluations. Human in the Loop adds context, interpretation, and specialized validation.
Together, these approaches make it possible to build more consistent evaluation processes, direct human review toward the cases that matter most, and monitor application quality throughout its lifecycle.
Beyond the technological novelty, the underlying problem remains the same one we have always faced in Quality Assurance: the result is only as good as the process used to evaluate it.
Decision-makers need to recognize this when approving budgets, team profiles, and AI roadmaps. Evaluation, including its criteria, reference datasets, and specialists’ time, must be considered from the very beginning of a project rather than treated as an optional stage.
Ensuring the quality of artificial intelligence applications goes beyond validating responses. It requires structuring evaluation processes, defining reliable criteria, and continuously monitoring model performance.
Zallpy supports companies in building and evolving artificial intelligence solutions by connecting software engineering, technical expertise, and AI strategies to each business’s specific needs.
If you want to understand how to apply these approaches to your projects and make your AI applications more reliable, get in touch with a Zallpy specialist.